I am referring to this soya milk pudding that I have raved about. In my post, I described it as "比豆花更好吃" (more delicious than soya bean curd).
Some times ago, a blog reader, *Ah Bii*, left me a comment to ask if the agar-agar powder in the recipe can be replaced by gelatin powder.
I promised to try it out and post the outcome.
Experiment 1: Substitute agar-agar powder with same amount of gelatin powder
As I read from some sources in the Internet that agar-agar powder and gelatin powder is substitute of each other, I went ahead to replace the same amount of agar-agar powder with gelatin powder.
I used 1 ½ tsp of gelatin powder, dissolved in 2 tbsp of water then added into the into hot soya milk/milk mixture.
Outcome: the pudding didn't set at all after refrigerating for one night. (Instead of using small cups, this time I only divided the pudding mixture into 3 portions and poured into 3 rectangle containers, I suspected this could be part of the reason that contributed to the failure as the pudding might be too thick to get set.)
Failed.
Experiment 2: Substitute agar-agar powder with 1 tbsp of konnyaku jelly powder
I found some konnyaku jelly powder in my fridge (I didn't measure but I estimated should be about one tbsp). In order not to waste, I re-cooked the pudding mixture, brought it to a boil and added in the konnayaku jelly powder, continued to cook for about 10 mins. This time I used small pudding moulds.
Outcome: the pudding set but only the surface, underneath the mixture was still watery.
Failed.
Conclusion
From now on, I will stick to agar-agar powder for this recipe.
So *Ah Bii* if you are reading this post, I suggest you follow the recipe to use agar-agar powder to avoid disappointment. :P
Hi, I have tried your soya milk pudding, may I at what stage should i add in the agar agar, mine was not set. :(
ReplyDeleteRegards,
Emily
Hi Emily,
ReplyDeleteI think this recipe is a bir tricky coz a friend of mine tried and she also told me her pudding didn't set.
However, I saw a couple of my blogger friends tried this recipe and their pudding were all nicely set.
I mix the agar-agar powder with milk and soya milk then just cook together and bring to a gentle boil. "Just in caee", I would suggest to continue to cook for a while before removing from heat.
Hope you will try again as this soya milk pudding is really very nice.
I think when adding gelatin into liquid, the liquid must be in big boil and keep stirring with a hand whisk otherwise the liquid will never get set. I like to combine agar agar powder with gelatin for some puddings and cake topping. It works well.
ReplyDeletehehehe, thanks for the experiments Angel! ^__^
ReplyDeleteAnncoo,
ReplyDeleteThanks for your sharing. :)
Can I add gelatin to hot liquip and continue cook?
*Ah Bii*,
ReplyDeleteYou are welcome!